Blogs

Write new blog
HughFW

Hugh on Newsnight Tonight

by HughFW published on

Ben Webster’s article in the Times today accuses me of ‘misleading’ the public about discards. Unfortunately he used barely any of the information or quotes I gave him yesterday. I want to set the record straight here, and I’m due to be on Newsnight tonight (Weds 14th May) to debate this further, so please tune in if you can.....

• The article says that fishermen will be forced to land ‘all the fish they catch.’

o This is not true. The ban only covers species of fish that are covered by catch limits: the commercially important species. So a species like the lesser dogfish which has no catch limits, and is one of the most discarded fish, will be exempt from the discard ban.

• Barrie Deas of the National Federation of Fisherman’s Organisations claims that the Fish Fight campaign supported a ‘simplistic, blunt ban’ on discards

o We have always maintained that fish which are proven to survive when thrown back into the sea should be exempt from the ban, and indeed the ban has been designed in a way that does allow these exemptions. We totally accept that the key to success is in careful, phased-in implementation that gives fishermen flexibility to adjust to the new rules. We fully support flexible quotas and quota exchange systems to help relieve the ‘quota chokes’ he mentions in the article.

• Mr Deas also says we have not given fishermen credit for their efforts to reduce discards so far.

o This is not true. One of the main features of the last episode was my fishing trip with the Budding Rose, one of around 30 boats fishing under the Catch Quota system that have virtually eliminated discards of cod. It is perhaps the best example of how fisherman in the North Sea are adapting their methods to reduce discards, and we specifically suggested that this approach could be crucial in restoring cod stocks to sustainable levels. A lot of public money is being made available to help fishermen adapt to this new challenge.


For the record: we only support a ban on discards if it is implemented in such a way that it brings the total number fish killed down to sustainable levels and helps to achieve stock recovery: this will of course be to the long term benefit of all fishermen. We believe this can only be achieved if fishermen use more selective gear that more effectively targets their quota species, and if quota rules are fit for purpose and set at sustainable levels.

1 reply
Replied on

I watched the interview on Newsnight last night. The whole thing was odd, Paxman was for once fairly quiet when he wasn't being his usual fairly rude.

I entirely missed who the chap sat opposite Hugh was, also who he represented. He gave us the distinct impression that he was on the payroll of someone who has a vested interest in seeing this "ban" on discards overturned. Hard to tell as really neither side put their case well, Paxman evidently hadn't done his homework and as a supporter of Hugh's fish fight I would like to hear more about this.

To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • . @clipperteas Lots of votes for the traditional roast, good shout! #cookeveryday
  • RT @clipperteas: @rivercottage We're going traditional roast beef, yorkshire pud & homemade gravy. Might even have sprouts & a glass of red…
  • @lewisslayden Sounds good. Bacon made by @lambposts perhaps? #cookeveryday
  • RT @lewisslayden: @rivercottage it simply has to be a proper full english breakfast, with good bread and proper bacon and sausages #cookeve…
  • RT @HappyDaysNo1: @rivercottage Desert Island dish? @jamieoliver 's Proper Bloke's Sausage Fusilli. #cookeveryday link
  • @ar_weston Yup, that's weird but it's your island so you can have them! #cookeveryday
  • @coffeecollins Yes, we'll let you have that on your des(s)ert island! #cookeveryday
  • RT @mdearlove: @rivercottage Ham, Egg, Chips - simple! #cookeveryday
  • We're enjoying your desert island dishes this morning. Keep 'em coming! #cookeveryday RT link
  • . @johnmushroom Delicious! With a side of #beetroot, yes? #cookeveryday
  • RT @johnmushroom: @rivercottage #cookeveryday Desert Island dish? Wood Blewits, garlic and cream on toast. link
  • RT @rose_rambles: Desert Island Dish? Spicy vegetarian green Thai curry. Yum! @rivercottage #cookeveryday link
  • @James_V67 good choice! #cookeveryday
  • RT @James_V67: @rivercottage beef bourguignon, no question. Could eat it for every meal. #cookeveryday
  • RT @BorderPigMan: What dish couldn't I do without? It's simple. Would have to involve eggs - probably in omelette form. #cookeveryday
  • @spillersfarm sounds good! #cookeveryday
  • RT @spillersfarm: @rivercottage My Desert Island Dish our own Roast Rare Breed Pork with crispy crackling, roasty spuds and all the trimmin…
  • Today we want to know your Desert Island Dish... What meal couldn't you live without? Go! Tag with #cookeveryday link
  • @maddimouse we have a new leader! #cookeveryday
  • RT @maddimouse: @rivercottage cookbooks? 145 plus loads of magazines. Almost everything on this photo! #cookeveryday link
  • @plant2plateuk this has been a popular choice today! #cookeveryday
  • @Thelittleshelfc bargain! #cookeveryday
  • @ComeToDinner @Bentholyptus think we're going to have to see photographic evidence! #cookeveryday
  • RT @mberzell: @rivercottage @Bentholyptus I counted 79 cook books in my book shelf. (and my fav is Veg Everyday) #cookeveryday
  • @BBQCabCo goodness, very well used! #cookeveryday
  • @HollyGMD lovely!
  • Wow @Bentholyptus has 70+ cookbooks, can anyone beat that? #cookeveryday
  • @dornerk pics of your fav cookbook - if that's an RC one, so be it! #cookeveryday
  • @foodshares first vote for this one! Nice! #cookeveryday
  • RT @foodshares: @rivercottage @Rick_Stein's Spain has to be one of my fav's, a great insight into food & culture! #cookeveryday http://t.co…
  • Any more favourite cookbooks for us? Bonus points for pictures! Tag your tweet with #cookeveryday link
  • You can watch all of Hugh’s brand new recipes on our #FoodTube channel - and there’s still more to come! https://t.co/bMEvVghJaR
  • Our favourite book at the moment is Light & Easy, and here’s Hugh’s pear cobbler pud - exclusively for #FoodTube https://t.co/U9FoV9YpMw
  • RT @VlaSoph: @rivercottage Global Vegetarian Kitchen for its simple and delicious food. Shown with my other faves! #cookeveryday http://t.c…
  • RT @Alex22cash: @rivercottage Um... tough question as this is only half my collection! #CookEveryday link
  • RT @HappyDaysNo1: @rivercottage My favourite has to be @jamieoliver At Home. Well used as you can see! #cookeveryday link
  • RT @bamptonboy: @rivercottage This is the cookbook that got me started and let me dabble now with other great books link
  • @flojoeasydetox Wow, you've definitely got your money's worth on that one! #cookeveryday
  • RT @flojoeasydetox: @rivercottage This is my favourite cookbook as you can see from the knackered spine! #cookeveryday link
  • @fayfran That is a well-loved copy. Favourite recipe from it? #cookeveryday
  • RT @fayfran: @rivercottage Fave cookbook has to be this battered, stained old thing from which I learned so much! #cookeveryday http://t.co…
  • @charlesnic Wow, quite a collection there! #cookeveryday
  • RT @coffeecollins: @jamieoliver Jamie's Italy - my fav cook book. I am going to spend a year in Amalfi and cook it all! #cookeveryday http:…
  • @catrinelisa Keeping it retro, nice! As for the cuppa, milk first or last? #teadebate #cookeveryday
  • RT @FeeEdden: @rivercottage for me it's @Nigella_Lawson 'Kitchen'. Beautifully written. Excellent recipes. Genius tips & hints. #cookeveryd…
  • @Roystoncanary Spoken like a true Canary! #cookeveryday
  • RT @juebagsx: @rivercottage Well - i think i have some problems making a decision! #cookeveryday link
  • Roll up, roll up... any more favourite cookbooks out there for us? Join the conversation on #cookeveryday link
  • . @johnmushroom Pipe down, you. It's delicious - especially with the optional vodka...
  • RT @TyrrellChef: #cookeveryday @rivercottage Marguerite Costa four seasons cookbook full of interesting simple dishes well before its time!…
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00