Forum

Start new topic
page 1/2 go to

Edible Freshwater Fish (create a list please)

spudhead
by spudhead
Hi Everyone,

This is my first post here, so apologies if this sounds a bit simple.

I'm thinking about catching some freshwater fish to eat.
(I'm a beginner at that too)

I'm wondering, apart from the obvious fly fishing for trout, was is edible in our UK canals, pools and rivers.

I've read about Pike in another post. So thanks for that.

I'm interested in what I can catch locally without paying to go to one of the trout farm in my area. Free is always best


Feel free to create a list. Thanks
last edited on
quixote_1
#1
by quixote_1
There are a lot of technically edible fish in lochs & rivers. I'm not a coarse fisherman, so I wouldn't have any idea as to whether it's acceptable to remove them though. Especially in the case of managed fisheries. However, to answer your question literally, the most commonly eaten fish are..................

Bream
Carp
Perch
Pike
Zander
Salmon
Trout
Grayling
Seatrout
Eels......................all edible (and quite delicious, from all accounts.)

Barbel
Tench
Chubb..................I've been told are completely inedible (not poisonous, just unpleasant)

Other species (roach, dace, rudd, etc) I can't help with, I'm afraid.................
spudhead
#2
by spudhead
thanks for the quick reply quixote_1

I've just read somewhere that you need a licence for freshwater fishing.

Is that true for all freshwater fishing?
Even trapping eels in a stream ?
Celtic Mike
#3
by Celtic Mike
You will need a rod license to fish on any fresh water and in addition you may well need another license to fish on rivers and certainly canals if there are established fishing rights. If you fish on a stream it may well be privately owned so again you would need a licence or permit or you would be poaching.

Its always best to ask first to make sure.
Moose
#4
by Moose
Just to add, having a licence doesn't necessarily entitle you to remove fish from a body of water. Where I live, I have an Environment Agency licence and a licence to fish the waters belonging to the district's waters, but am only allowed to remove Pike up to 6lb, Zander, and what the association classes as game fish (brown trout, rainbow trout and salmon - they don't class grayling as a game fish).

Such a shame, as the perch and bream fishing here is good!
There are only 10 types of people in the world - those who understand binary, and those who don't.
KEITH BROWN
#5
by KEITH BROWN
I can recommend Pike and Perch from a clean water, for example at my back gate is the Bridgewater Canal, the water quality in the cut has improved over the last decade but still I would not eat any catch from it.
You have to seek clean bodies of water such as the Lochs in Scotland or the Lake District, I’ve eaten Perch as a lad but would not do so now purely for conservation reasons, i.e. let them grow bigger.
Pike I still eat, only up to eight pounds in weight, anything larger tends to be tougher.
doniv
#6
by doniv
I think everyone should be Forced to eat a bream - just so we can get rid of this Myth that they're edible

You may not actually die but they are truly foul
'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
quixote_1
#7
by quixote_1
Hmmm, interesting! I was always under the impression that they were quite nice. Maybe I'm getting mixed up with sea bream?
Mart
#8
by Mart
I have a recipe for a river fish stew that calls amongst other things for a few small tench. Anyone ever eaten a tench ?
Oneforthepot
#9
by Oneforthepot
My fishmonger sells freshwater bream - and says they're vile - but they still sell.

Gudgeon are really good prepared like sardines.

Zander are as close to cod as you'll find unless you happen upon burbot ( now extinct in this country ).

Crucian carp are ok - bony but the bones are thick and solid - easy to pick out, what I usualy end up with is bizzarre crucian/goldfish hybrids.

Orfe/ide are supposed to be very good.

I've got a freshwater fish book ( long out of print ) which reviews the eating qualities of the fish. Did you know sticklebacks used to be collected and rendered for oil?
fungi2bwith
#10
by fungi2bwith
I have eaten most freshwater fish (but not chub, barbel, or tench) and think they are all worthwhile. However, they are very variable and this is probably due to water quality. I have seen lots of advice on eating only those from flowing water and this is good advice but the water quality isn't always obvious and varies throughout the year. Therefore I suggest you should not give up on a species before trying several different venues (and cooking methods).

For example I have eaten lots of freshwater eel but by far the best were a couple I caught from Lake Windemere. Probably the best tasting course fish in my opinion is Perch.

One word of warning there has been a lot of reports in the Angling press on Eastern Europeans taking lots of fish for the table and this has led to a number of over reactions from other fisherman. So I suggest only a few fish are taken and it is done discreetly (and within the local by-laws).
page 1/2 go to
To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • A beautiful sunset over the valley tonight! link
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Welcoming our first #Trainees to River Cottage - the first step of their 3 month work experience programme. link
  • Hey @nationaltrust still looking for lovely frosty pics? :o)
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Wrap up warm, it's frosty out there! link
  • RT @plymouthcanteen: Feeling hungry this lunch time... Visit @plymouthcanteen for 3 small plates for only £10! link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Tickets just released for our @sohsteve gig on 22 May, which kick starts our #RCFoodFair weekend. Grab a ticket now! ht…
  • Make the most of your oven's energy, cook meals in bulk where poss. Reheating uses less energy. Top tip via @wwwfoecouk
  • . @johnmushroom looks like someone needs a #selfie stick!
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: We have discounted tickets available for this Sunday's dining experience. Gather your loved ones + come on down! https:…
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: The only thing blue about our Monday is the sky. #BlueMonday link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Want to meet @GillMeller and hear about his forthcoming book #pigsandpork? Don't miss this! https://t.co/MHIsUvUb7t htt…
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Gain work-experience in our @RCChefsSchool – free traineeships starting 26 Jan – travel expenses paid. link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: How much cake is too much cake? The fruits of our labour from today's #cake course in our #cookeryschool... http://t.co…
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Hooray! #pastrysuccess #choux link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Oh dear #pastryfail link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Time for our third breakfast of the day. It's a hard life at our #cookeryschool... link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Time for a second breakfast at the #cookeryschool... Drop scones with runny honey. link
  • @anneHuscroft1 so lovely to hear, thanks Anne! Any plans to come back to the farm soon?
  • RT @Hartsturkeys: Great stuff @ChefTomKerridge @BBCFoodandDrink @rivercottage. The best 30mins of TV this week. Looking forward to @Corriga
  • RT @jiholland111: @rivercottage @BBCFoodandDrink Great show. Excellent banter with @ChefTomKerridge :)
  • @linsalad @BBCFoodandDrink glad to hear it :o)
  • Hope you are all enjoying Hugh on @BBCFoodandDrink right now, BBC2!
  • @CharlotteClare1 sorry, blame Hugh!
  • And of course we couldn't let Hugh go without a birthday cake #50yearsofHugh #AskHugh link
  • And if you'd like to buy the book, check it out here! #lightandeasy #askHugh link
  • Thank you, its been great chatting! Have to dash, making a birthday cake for a fellow 50-year-old. Chocolate + hazelnut, pg 374! #askHugh
  • .@Eco_Gite It spreads like mad so not in the veg patch, better in a big pot, but it does take nearly a year to produce good sized roots.
  • . @Lou_la_may Default topping is a sprinkling of soft brown sugar but a trickle of runny honey is also great. #askHugh
  • .@trishaocf Could be your choice of flour or that your sd starter needs a feed up, take a good tblsp, feed it for a few days & start again.
  • . @bookslinger always lovely to hear that people are cooking from my books and enjoying the results! #askHugh
  • .@harrycornwall Cider is a good choice, I would choose a fairly dry one as the onions are quite sweet #AskHugh
  • . @_DjTC_ soon! Early Feb is good, provided you can keep them frost-free. A sunny window is good. #askHugh
  • .@IantheCW I'm all over the roots right now, big trays of them roasted and finished with a sprinkling of toasted seeds and spices #AskHugh
  • . @ACoSfChildren but it's so flat! Actually I do have a soft spot for Norfolk and it's been a while so who knows. #askHugh
  • .@rojob1 Yes, series 3 coming your way very soon and as ever Paul champions the sustainable approach to fish, veg and meat #AskHugh
  • . @missaniela really sorry but I'm not around for that one. I will be here for the Spring Food Fair in May... #askHugh
  • .@pupspigspoulets We said goodbye to our Oxford Sandy & Blacks before Christmas, they were fab! We like ringing the changes though. #AskHugh
  • . @bookslinger It's always a treat to be given other people's goodies. Of course I try them! #askHugh
  • .@GrowandEat That's a tough one to comment on without knowing the whole picture.
  • . @MyrtlesGarden there's a lovely potato gnocchi recipe in RC Veg and you could swap a GF flour in for the wheat flour. #askHugh
  • .@pickleshlee A good way to deliver vitamins and fibre but not to be drunk by the gallon as they are often quite high in sugar #AskHugh
  • . @AmberLofts523 that's better than a birthday suit! #askHugh
  • . @NellieRBean once it's all mixed up you should keep in the fridge and eat within two days #askHugh
  • .@acornwoodcraft I like dual purpose varieties eg Light Sussex Dumpies & Road Island Reds, but Hubbards are good free range modern meat bird
  • . @EmzJ_Smith It's a great campaign, we should be eating this lovely stuff. Let's hope supermarkets get the message @jamieoliver #askHugh
  • .@dikparkes I'll be back in the Autumn with a brand new series - something a bit different too! #AskHugh
  • . @beanbrackets That sounds like my dear Uncle Will - an outstanding gardener and all round top bloke. #askHugh
  • .@petermartindk Grow vertically to max returns. E.G. Climbing peas & beans, plus herbs you like best, thyme, sage and Rosemary are my favs.
  • . @Cooked_UK There are lots I hope. Check out the salad section for some zingy and elegant #lightandeasy starters. #askHugh
  • .@bantam1977 I would love to do that but the place would have to be just right, who knows it could happen one day.
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00