Forum

Start new topic
page 1/2 go to

Edible Freshwater Fish (create a list please)

spudhead
by spudhead
Hi Everyone,

This is my first post here, so apologies if this sounds a bit simple.

I'm thinking about catching some freshwater fish to eat.
(I'm a beginner at that too)

I'm wondering, apart from the obvious fly fishing for trout, was is edible in our UK canals, pools and rivers.

I've read about Pike in another post. So thanks for that.

I'm interested in what I can catch locally without paying to go to one of the trout farm in my area. Free is always best


Feel free to create a list. Thanks
last edited on
quixote_1
#1
by quixote_1
There are a lot of technically edible fish in lochs & rivers. I'm not a coarse fisherman, so I wouldn't have any idea as to whether it's acceptable to remove them though. Especially in the case of managed fisheries. However, to answer your question literally, the most commonly eaten fish are..................

Bream
Carp
Perch
Pike
Zander
Salmon
Trout
Grayling
Seatrout
Eels......................all edible (and quite delicious, from all accounts.)

Barbel
Tench
Chubb..................I've been told are completely inedible (not poisonous, just unpleasant)

Other species (roach, dace, rudd, etc) I can't help with, I'm afraid.................
spudhead
#2
by spudhead
thanks for the quick reply quixote_1

I've just read somewhere that you need a licence for freshwater fishing.

Is that true for all freshwater fishing?
Even trapping eels in a stream ?
Celtic Mike
#3
by Celtic Mike
You will need a rod license to fish on any fresh water and in addition you may well need another license to fish on rivers and certainly canals if there are established fishing rights. If you fish on a stream it may well be privately owned so again you would need a licence or permit or you would be poaching.

Its always best to ask first to make sure.
Moose
#4
by Moose
Just to add, having a licence doesn't necessarily entitle you to remove fish from a body of water. Where I live, I have an Environment Agency licence and a licence to fish the waters belonging to the district's waters, but am only allowed to remove Pike up to 6lb, Zander, and what the association classes as game fish (brown trout, rainbow trout and salmon - they don't class grayling as a game fish).

Such a shame, as the perch and bream fishing here is good!
There are only 10 types of people in the world - those who understand binary, and those who don't.
KEITH BROWN
#5
by KEITH BROWN
I can recommend Pike and Perch from a clean water, for example at my back gate is the Bridgewater Canal, the water quality in the cut has improved over the last decade but still I would not eat any catch from it.
You have to seek clean bodies of water such as the Lochs in Scotland or the Lake District, I’ve eaten Perch as a lad but would not do so now purely for conservation reasons, i.e. let them grow bigger.
Pike I still eat, only up to eight pounds in weight, anything larger tends to be tougher.
doniv
#6
by doniv
I think everyone should be Forced to eat a bream - just so we can get rid of this Myth that they're edible

You may not actually die but they are truly foul
'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
quixote_1
#7
by quixote_1
Hmmm, interesting! I was always under the impression that they were quite nice. Maybe I'm getting mixed up with sea bream?
Mart
#8
by Mart
I have a recipe for a river fish stew that calls amongst other things for a few small tench. Anyone ever eaten a tench ?
Oneforthepot
#9
by Oneforthepot
My fishmonger sells freshwater bream - and says they're vile - but they still sell.

Gudgeon are really good prepared like sardines.

Zander are as close to cod as you'll find unless you happen upon burbot ( now extinct in this country ).

Crucian carp are ok - bony but the bones are thick and solid - easy to pick out, what I usualy end up with is bizzarre crucian/goldfish hybrids.

Orfe/ide are supposed to be very good.

I've got a freshwater fish book ( long out of print ) which reviews the eating qualities of the fish. Did you know sticklebacks used to be collected and rendered for oil?
fungi2bwith
#10
by fungi2bwith
I have eaten most freshwater fish (but not chub, barbel, or tench) and think they are all worthwhile. However, they are very variable and this is probably due to water quality. I have seen lots of advice on eating only those from flowing water and this is good advice but the water quality isn't always obvious and varies throughout the year. Therefore I suggest you should not give up on a species before trying several different venues (and cooking methods).

For example I have eaten lots of freshwater eel but by far the best were a couple I caught from Lake Windemere. Probably the best tasting course fish in my opinion is Perch.

One word of warning there has been a lot of reports in the Angling press on Eastern Europeans taking lots of fish for the table and this has led to a number of over reactions from other fisherman. So I suggest only a few fish are taken and it is done discreetly (and within the local by-laws).
page 1/2 go to
To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • RT @harriet_grose: I have to say my Mum got me into cooking, from a very early age!! #agaliving #countrylife @RiverCottageHQ #cookeveryday
  • RT @SuzanneMoulson: @rivercottage Both my (wonderful) parents encouraged me to cook, I made the best Yorkshire Puddings by the age of 9 #yu…
  • @KirstieMAllsopp Hello! Could you follow us back? We'd like to DM you about something...
  • RT @Loztastique: @rivercottage #cookeveryday my gran. She had a simple strategy - good ingredients cooked simply. And lemon & cream improve…
  • #22 for #cookeveryday is - what got you into cooking? Perhaps a friend, family member, teacher or TV show?
  • RT @TinaTinaMay: @rivercottage I was made to eat that terrible mash made out of powder as a kid...why, when I could have had proper yummy b…
  • Any more for #21 of #cookeveryday? We're asking for food you were made to eat as a kid, lots of good answers so far! link
  • RT @GelfAlderson: @rivercottage was brought up as a vegetarian, rice flan always stuck with me, it summed up vegetarian cookery at its wors…
  • RT @HappyDaysNo1: @rivercottage I was made to eat liver and bacon casserole. I appreciate it now but wasn't such a fan as a kid. #cookevery…
  • RT @beckybeasley: @rivercottage lentil loaf, me and sis used to sneak it to the dog. #cookeveryday
  • RT @Bentholyptus: @rivercottage #everything. if I didn't eat everything on plate I couldn't leave dinner table. Suprised I'm not 20st #cook…
  • @NickKillingback Hmm, tricky. Let's ask @johnmushroom... #mushrooming
  • RT @allybag1: Gristle!!! Every bit of meat! Had to stay at the table till it was all gone ! Don't eat meat now ! #cookeveryday
  • RT @roryos31: @rivercottage #cookeveryday .My dad a chef loved making us eat all sorts -heart, pigs head , pigs feet etc.Not left leave ta…
  • It's time for #21 of #cookeveryday. What were you made to eat as a kid? Go! link
  • RT @AnnaPitt: @rivercottage fave autumn treat: bonfire, mulled wine, pumpkin soup and the glow of pumpkin lanterns #cookeveryday
  • @jonnytbonewils over to @lambposts...
  • WATCH: Make your own traditional apple and blackberry fruit leather with @thepamthejam link #cookeveryday
  • RT @Alpro_UK: We’re whipping up our hazelnut orange custard @RiverCottage – it's one of our fave autumn treats! #cookeveryday link
  • RT @plymouthcanteen: An exciting opportunity has arisen for a new Head Chef here at the Plymouth Canteen link
  • RT @thetimes: Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall on how his mum taught him to bake, only in today's @thetimes (@rivercottage) link
  • RT @comeconella: @rivercottage all things butternut! #cookeveryday
  • @JayAllen33 @RiverCottageHQ good question! Let's ask @lambposts...
  • RT @CoopFayB: @rivercottage blackberry & apple crumble. Perfect from the picking through to the eating. #cookeveryday
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage My fave autumn treat? It's spring in Oz, so I'm gonna say rhubarb!! #cookeveryday
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage My favourite autumn treat: has to be treacle toffee. #cookeveryday
  • Happy Monday all! #20 on #cookeveryday is favourite autumn treats (edible or otherwise) - let's hear them now... link
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage Veg I grow in my garden: None this year. I grow fruit and want to grow more veg, if slugs will let me! #coo…
  • RT @truss_abbie: @rivercottage #cookeveryday grow veg on my allotment but in the garden is fennel...lots of other herbs and wild garlic in …
  • #19 for #cookeveryday is all about veg. What do you grow in your garden? #growyourown link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: . @rivercottage we love ALL cheese, especially that made by @tomthecheese on our course! link #cooker…
  • RT @lisa_spelling: @rivercottage all of them!! But especially Waterloo and stinking bishop and sharpham rustic with a large glass of port! …
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage Cheese of choice? Too hard! I love them all! Something French, creamy & smelly... Mmm... #cookeveryday
  • Morning #cookeveryday fans! Time for #18, what's your favourite cheese? link
  • Hugh helped raise money for #StandUpToCancer with @starservice! Can you help too? link
  • RT @rose_rambles: @rivercottage My family's favourite cake to make & eat: vanilla sponge filled with cream & sliced pear #cookeveryday http…
  • RT @whitstabob: @rivercottage it's presently Lemon, lavender and almond because it's the only edible one I've ever made! link
  • #17 for #cookeveryday: what's your favourite cake to make / eat? Go! link
  • Hungry? Find high welfare meat retailers near you link @PigBusiness link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Come together to toast the #festive period with a seasonal aperitif & a roaring log fire in our yurt. Book now! http://…
  • RT @johnmushroom: @rivercottage #cookeveryday. Not yet mastered? Pastry. But how hard can it be? River Cottage Handbook needed, I think.
  • Keep your #cookeveryday answers coming - what cookery course would you like to do? What skill have you yet to master? link
  • Vote with your wallet. Watch @PigBusiness’ 3-minute video and sign the #PigPledge link
  • Today's #cookeveryday is: what's your ideal cookery course? What would you most like to learn? #cookeryschool
  • The new 3 minute #PigPledge video reveals the true cost of cheap pork - watch, share and sign! link
  • RT @BloomsburyCooks: Fantastic day today spent down in the farm @rivercottage - we got to ride on a tractor?! WINNING link
  • Keep your favourite chefs coming in - and remember to tag with #cookeveryday. Lots of love for @jamieoliver @rick_stein @Ottolenghi, Hugh...
  • RT @Lanzy_88: @rivercottage fav chefs wud have to be Hugh and the Hairy Bikers #cookeveryday
  • @hugo_harrison Assume you've seen Hugh's new one, #lightandeasy? It's packed with #wheatfree and #dairyfree recipes: link
  • RT @WinCanteen: Who's coming to meet Hugh tomorrow? He will be here at 10.30am to meet guests and sign his new book @rivercottage
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00