Forum

Start new topic
page 2/4 go to

generator that can produce "free energy"

jimcrow
#11
by jimcrow

So what is Perpetual motion?

Pippa G
#12
by Pippa G

I've always been a bit thick when it comes to physics but doesn't the fact that it's powered by magnets mean that it's not 'energy from nothing'? It's simply somehow converting magnetism into motion and then utilising the energy of the motion? Or am I totally out?

ozzi
#13
by ozzi

Me too Pippa, but perpetual motion is physically impossible as each iteration is minutely slowed by inertia and without a power boost of some sort then that slowing process eventually results in stoppage. Hence the inability to achieve perpetual motion without something coming along and giving it a boost. The simplest example is a child on a swing. Unless the adult comes along and gives it a push occasionally, the child eventually stops swinging and is stationary.

If you can't see the light at the end of the tunnel - run down there and light the blooming thing yourself!
jimcrow
#14
by jimcrow

I`ve watched that Youtube video of the generator,its kick started by a battery,so i presume,its the magnets that keep pulling it around.

The comment by Jordan,that its not possible by the law of physics,

I presume your familiar with Earth magnets,think thats the right name,

The safetylamps we used underground could only be opened with a magnet,about 2in thick,and the width of the lamp around 3 1/2 ins,today an earth magnet the size of your thumb nail will do the job,them Orientals are clever chaps.

alchemist
#15
by alchemist

There are various substances which have different amounts of magnetism, so some magnets will be a lot stronger than others. There has been a lot of work done over recent years on magnets, superconductors, organic conductors and batteries. I suspect this earth magnet is a spin off from that work.

There must be some input into any machine to keep it going as there are things like friction, air resistance, gravity, losses between one form of energy (movement) to another (electicity for instance) to overcome.

doniv
#16
by doniv

The original poster never claimed "perpetual motion" (although they have got VERY close - with supercooled conductors)- just "Free energy" - just like the windmills and water wheels - and gravity engines ! Cool

'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
alchemist
#17
by alchemist

Supercooled conductors are very good, but think of all the energy that has to be used to keep them supercooled. A lot of work has been carried out over the last few years on superconductors. One of the main aims of the work is to raise the temperature at which they become superconducting from near absolute zero to nearer room temperature. Not sure what the current record is, but may be possible to cool them with something like liquid carbon dioxide now rather than liquid nitrogen or oxygen.

doniv
#18
by doniv

That may all be very interesting alcy Cool 

 

But the moment you start using them to do work - you're introducing a resistance which is going to kill perpetual motion - IMHO

 

UNlike the "free  energy machines" which don't claim to be "perpetual motion - just to perpetually keep moving - and probably allowing some power take off Laughing - If some trickery of using natural resources like gravity or magnetism can be harnessed - then it's "Free energy" as per the original post - at least, as my understanding of it ! 

 

 

 

'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
Pippa G
#19
by Pippa G

I think that's how I understood it too. If you can use electricity to produce magnetism, then why not magnetism to produce electricity? Or am I really just showing my thickness where physics is concerned?

doniv
#20
by doniv

 

 

Not at all - that's how cars produce electricity - moving wire in a magnetic field ! Cool

 

 In fact windmills and water turbines use it too to produce their versions of "free electricity" Surprised

 

 

'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
last edited on
page 2/4 go to
To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • Entries for our #RisingStar 2014 competition are open! Who wants to be the next face of our #appenticeship scheme? link
  • WATCH: Paul West and @gillmeller make Sea Bass, Sorrel and Peas. Can you spot who is having a kip in the background?! link
  • @lollifloss @jamieoliver @lorrainepascale @Nigella_Lawson Our Hugh has some ideas here: link Enjoy!
  • RT @lollifloss: What do I do with MUTANT COURGETTES? @jamieoliver @rivercottage @lorrainepascale @Nigella_Lawson link
  • RT @AlexGoochbaker: I agree entirely @rivercottage link
  • WATCH: @Joe_Sugg spends a day with us finding our about our young chef apprenticeship scheme... link
  • @emmacouttie Sounds dodgy! Name and shame? #meatpledge
  • Hey @DrinksTube our raspberries are just coming into season, can you knock us up a fruity number? #CocktailRequest link
  • RT @MarketingLiz: @rivercottage love your meat pledge. Seems ludicrous that a restaurant would consider anything else. Too few values in ou…
  • RT @heather_grace13: @guardian @rivercottage i'm vegetarian
  • In the light of @guardian's chicken investigation, now seems like a good time to take our #meatpledge RT NOW! link
  • RT @guardian: Find out why the drive for cheaper chicken is making more than 250,000 of us sick every year link
  • Last few tickets remaining for @WildernessHQ don't miss! Lovely @GillMeller will be there... link link
  • RT @johnmushroom: Two failed seasons but things look very promising @rivercottage this year. link
  • RT @draperjoe: Looking for a talented foodie sous chef to work with me @plymouthcanteen @rivercottage #getintouch #chef pls RT
  • RT @DrinksTube: Loads of you've asked for more time to create your #CocktailStar entries so we've extended the deadline by two weeks http:/…
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Waiting for your big break? This is your chance - come and be the face of River Cottage link #chef #fo…
  • RT @WinCanteen: JOBS GALORE! Fancy working with us? Check out our vacancies or visit us at our open day on Thursday. More info: http://t.co…
  • Coming later today on #foodtube - a foraging treat with @johnmushroom and @RiverCottageAus's Paul West. Don't miss! link
  • RT @RCHQEvents: We've just released tickets for New Year's Eve. We'd hate you to miss out! link link
  • RT @Rethink_: Exciting meeting with @rivercottage team to discuss ways cooking can help improve confidence. Watch this space! link
  • RT @DrinksTube: All next week we want YOU to inspire us with a #CocktailRequest. Jamie's here with everything you need to know https://t.co…
  • We have our first entry! MT @kishanpatel96: This is my rising star 2014 entry please check it out and vote, thanks!! link
  • RT @RCHQEvents: Up close and personal with our Nettle. link
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Happy Friday! Create a cooking video this weekend and you could be our next star chef. How about a BBQ vid? link
  • Hi @alt_J we read your recent interview in @guardian - if you did want to literally read aloud from our books, we'd love to send you some!
  • RT @axcanteen: Have a lazy morning, leave the cooking to us and we'll whip you up a hearty breakfast link
  • WATCH: Meet @samjlomas, our winner from last year's #RisingStar comp. Thinking of entering? link link
  • RT @SoilAssociation: 'City of Fremantle in #Australia bans plastic bags and imposes fines of up to $2,500' via @Guardian link
  • RT @plymouthcanteen: We have a fab selection of fresh, locally sourced deli items - if you're enjoying a stroll around @royalwilliamyd pop …
  • Are you creating avoidable waste with your lunchtime sarnies? RT @wwwfoecouk Homemade sandwiches for lunch? link
  • @thepamthejam @pipcourtney All details can be found here: link Should be a fantastic day!
  • RT @jamieoliver: SO EXCITING! @DrinksTube's #CocktailRequest Week starts on Monday. Watch this vid & then send them some inspiration! http:…
  • Bottle up your raspberries for a little #summer goodness in winter. Learn with @thepamthejam link link
  • @_Hugh_Chapman we just gave you a shout out :o) Hope that helps!
  • Based in Cambridge? Can you help? RT @_Hugh_Chapman I'm looking for a landshare-type opportunity for organic veg growing near Cambridge ...
  • RT @WinCanteen: We are at the #Winchester Guildhall NOW until 5pm today... come on down and find out about jobs at our new canteen! http://…
  • Coming up later on #foodtube our @thepamthejam shows how to bottle raspberries with a little sloe gin #delicious #preserving @JamiesFoodTube
  • @_Hugh_Chapman Hello. I'm afraid there is no further funding for this project. Should the situation change, we will let you know. Sorry!
  • RT @RCHQEvents: Great photo blog from @LibertyLndnGirl about her visit to our farm. Check it out here: link
  • Let’ see them! RT @madamchebly: @rivercottage : I'm trying to persuade my son in law to enter but he's way too modest about his talents
  • RT @CityandGuildsPR: Do you have what it takes to be the next Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall? Apply to be @rivercottage's #RisingStar 2014 - h…
  • We're delivering 1920 bottles of our fine EPA beer to @ocado tomorrow - exciting!
  • RT @RCHQEvents: Got your tickets yet for Hugh's Late Summer Party? We'll be launching a new book + hosting the Rising Star final: http://t.…
  • RT @samjlomas: River Cottage Rising Star 2014 is open again! link @CityandGuildsAC @Springboard_UK @Seachangeagency
  • RT @veeeenr: Foodtube fun & sneak peak into the life of an apprentice at amazing @rivercottage with my little duck @freyjaceleste http://t.…
  • RT @DavinaLovegreen: @rivercottage This is brilliant. I started as a YTS..Now I have my own company. Producing all meat from own farm,makin…
  • @GBPoultry yup!
  • RT @TheFlexitarian: Intermarché fights #foodwaste “Inglorious Fruits & Vegetables” ugly made beautiful link link
  • Could you impress the judges + be the face of Rising Star? There's only one way to find out... link link
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00