Forum

Start new topic
page 2/4 go to

generator that can produce "free energy"

jimcrow
#11
by jimcrow

So what is Perpetual motion?

Pippa G
#12
by Pippa G

I've always been a bit thick when it comes to physics but doesn't the fact that it's powered by magnets mean that it's not 'energy from nothing'? It's simply somehow converting magnetism into motion and then utilising the energy of the motion? Or am I totally out?

ozzi
#13
by ozzi

Me too Pippa, but perpetual motion is physically impossible as each iteration is minutely slowed by inertia and without a power boost of some sort then that slowing process eventually results in stoppage. Hence the inability to achieve perpetual motion without something coming along and giving it a boost. The simplest example is a child on a swing. Unless the adult comes along and gives it a push occasionally, the child eventually stops swinging and is stationary.

If you can't see the light at the end of the tunnel - run down there and light the blooming thing yourself!
jimcrow
#14
by jimcrow

I`ve watched that Youtube video of the generator,its kick started by a battery,so i presume,its the magnets that keep pulling it around.

The comment by Jordan,that its not possible by the law of physics,

I presume your familiar with Earth magnets,think thats the right name,

The safetylamps we used underground could only be opened with a magnet,about 2in thick,and the width of the lamp around 3 1/2 ins,today an earth magnet the size of your thumb nail will do the job,them Orientals are clever chaps.

alchemist
#15
by alchemist

There are various substances which have different amounts of magnetism, so some magnets will be a lot stronger than others. There has been a lot of work done over recent years on magnets, superconductors, organic conductors and batteries. I suspect this earth magnet is a spin off from that work.

There must be some input into any machine to keep it going as there are things like friction, air resistance, gravity, losses between one form of energy (movement) to another (electicity for instance) to overcome.

doniv
#16
by doniv

The original poster never claimed "perpetual motion" (although they have got VERY close - with supercooled conductors)- just "Free energy" - just like the windmills and water wheels - and gravity engines ! Cool

'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
alchemist
#17
by alchemist

Supercooled conductors are very good, but think of all the energy that has to be used to keep them supercooled. A lot of work has been carried out over the last few years on superconductors. One of the main aims of the work is to raise the temperature at which they become superconducting from near absolute zero to nearer room temperature. Not sure what the current record is, but may be possible to cool them with something like liquid carbon dioxide now rather than liquid nitrogen or oxygen.

doniv
#18
by doniv

That may all be very interesting alcy Cool 

 

But the moment you start using them to do work - you're introducing a resistance which is going to kill perpetual motion - IMHO

 

UNlike the "free  energy machines" which don't claim to be "perpetual motion - just to perpetually keep moving - and probably allowing some power take off Laughing - If some trickery of using natural resources like gravity or magnetism can be harnessed - then it's "Free energy" as per the original post - at least, as my understanding of it ! 

 

 

 

'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
Pippa G
#19
by Pippa G

I think that's how I understood it too. If you can use electricity to produce magnetism, then why not magnetism to produce electricity? Or am I really just showing my thickness where physics is concerned?

doniv
#20
by doniv

 

 

Not at all - that's how cars produce electricity - moving wire in a magnetic field ! Cool

 

 In fact windmills and water turbines use it too to produce their versions of "free electricity" Surprised

 

 

'Tis the time's plague, when madmen lead the blind. - Shakespear - King Lear
last edited on
page 2/4 go to
To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Only 7 tickets left for our @martinharley gig in April. Don't miss out! https://t.co/H8x7p0PrL8 link
  • A beautiful sunset over the valley tonight! link
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Welcoming our first #Trainees to River Cottage - the first step of their 3 month work experience programme. link
  • Hey @nationaltrust still looking for lovely frosty pics? :o)
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Wrap up warm, it's frosty out there! link
  • RT @plymouthcanteen: Feeling hungry this lunch time... Visit @plymouthcanteen for 3 small plates for only £10! link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Tickets just released for our @sohsteve gig on 22 May, which kick starts our #RCFoodFair weekend. Grab a ticket now! ht…
  • Make the most of your oven's energy, cook meals in bulk where poss. Reheating uses less energy. Top tip via @wwwfoecouk
  • . @johnmushroom looks like someone needs a #selfie stick!
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: We have discounted tickets available for this Sunday's dining experience. Gather your loved ones + come on down! https:…
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: The only thing blue about our Monday is the sky. #BlueMonday link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Want to meet @GillMeller and hear about his forthcoming book #pigsandpork? Don't miss this! https://t.co/MHIsUvUb7t htt…
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Gain work-experience in our @RCChefsSchool – free traineeships starting 26 Jan – travel expenses paid. link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: How much cake is too much cake? The fruits of our labour from today's #cake course in our #cookeryschool... http://t.co…
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Hooray! #pastrysuccess #choux link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Oh dear #pastryfail link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Time for our third breakfast of the day. It's a hard life at our #cookeryschool... link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Time for a second breakfast at the #cookeryschool... Drop scones with runny honey. link
  • @anneHuscroft1 so lovely to hear, thanks Anne! Any plans to come back to the farm soon?
  • RT @Hartsturkeys: Great stuff @ChefTomKerridge @BBCFoodandDrink @rivercottage. The best 30mins of TV this week. Looking forward to @Corriga
  • RT @jiholland111: @rivercottage @BBCFoodandDrink Great show. Excellent banter with @ChefTomKerridge :)
  • @linsalad @BBCFoodandDrink glad to hear it :o)
  • Hope you are all enjoying Hugh on @BBCFoodandDrink right now, BBC2!
  • @CharlotteClare1 sorry, blame Hugh!
  • And of course we couldn't let Hugh go without a birthday cake #50yearsofHugh #AskHugh link
  • And if you'd like to buy the book, check it out here! #lightandeasy #askHugh link
  • Thank you, its been great chatting! Have to dash, making a birthday cake for a fellow 50-year-old. Chocolate + hazelnut, pg 374! #askHugh
  • .@Eco_Gite It spreads like mad so not in the veg patch, better in a big pot, but it does take nearly a year to produce good sized roots.
  • . @Lou_la_may Default topping is a sprinkling of soft brown sugar but a trickle of runny honey is also great. #askHugh
  • .@trishaocf Could be your choice of flour or that your sd starter needs a feed up, take a good tblsp, feed it for a few days & start again.
  • . @bookslinger always lovely to hear that people are cooking from my books and enjoying the results! #askHugh
  • .@harrycornwall Cider is a good choice, I would choose a fairly dry one as the onions are quite sweet #AskHugh
  • . @_DjTC_ soon! Early Feb is good, provided you can keep them frost-free. A sunny window is good. #askHugh
  • .@IantheCW I'm all over the roots right now, big trays of them roasted and finished with a sprinkling of toasted seeds and spices #AskHugh
  • . @ACoSfChildren but it's so flat! Actually I do have a soft spot for Norfolk and it's been a while so who knows. #askHugh
  • .@rojob1 Yes, series 3 coming your way very soon and as ever Paul champions the sustainable approach to fish, veg and meat #AskHugh
  • . @missaniela really sorry but I'm not around for that one. I will be here for the Spring Food Fair in May... #askHugh
  • .@pupspigspoulets We said goodbye to our Oxford Sandy & Blacks before Christmas, they were fab! We like ringing the changes though. #AskHugh
  • . @bookslinger It's always a treat to be given other people's goodies. Of course I try them! #askHugh
  • .@GrowandEat That's a tough one to comment on without knowing the whole picture.
  • . @MyrtlesGarden there's a lovely potato gnocchi recipe in RC Veg and you could swap a GF flour in for the wheat flour. #askHugh
  • .@pickleshlee A good way to deliver vitamins and fibre but not to be drunk by the gallon as they are often quite high in sugar #AskHugh
  • . @AmberLofts523 that's better than a birthday suit! #askHugh
  • . @NellieRBean once it's all mixed up you should keep in the fridge and eat within two days #askHugh
  • .@acornwoodcraft I like dual purpose varieties eg Light Sussex Dumpies & Road Island Reds, but Hubbards are good free range modern meat bird
  • . @EmzJ_Smith It's a great campaign, we should be eating this lovely stuff. Let's hope supermarkets get the message @jamieoliver #askHugh
  • .@dikparkes I'll be back in the Autumn with a brand new series - something a bit different too! #AskHugh
  • . @beanbrackets That sounds like my dear Uncle Will - an outstanding gardener and all round top bloke. #askHugh
  • .@petermartindk Grow vertically to max returns. E.G. Climbing peas & beans, plus herbs you like best, thyme, sage and Rosemary are my favs.
  • . @Cooked_UK There are lots I hope. Check out the salad section for some zingy and elegant #lightandeasy starters. #askHugh
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00