Questions

Ask a question

Different type of fish

asked by David Hilton on
,

With us being urged at the moment to try different more sustainable types of fish I recently tried a new species that I have seen on display in a couple of supermarkets.
"River Cobbler". Apparently it is farmed in Vietnam. It was quite cheap, 99p for a decent size fillet.
What I would like to ask is ; with it being farmed in vietnam what quality of life does the fish have and are the fish farmers fairly paid for thier work.
It is no use us eating alternative fish to cod if that itself is going to result in other fish being bred in cramped conditions and third world people being exploited.
Can anyone throw any light on this fish?

4 answers
Answered on

The "thou blackguard" web page actually confirms many of the substantive things the other claims, apart from the pollution one. Industrial fish farming in specially dug ponds, fed on marine fish from one side of the world, product shipped to the other side...

I did not offer any opinion on cobbler itself: my post raised several questions which should be asked before buying any farmed fish. I can't yet find a source which answers them satisfactorily for this species.

Richard

Answered on

Sorry, but this is a scare story from 3 years ago in France, which had no foundation then, and does not now.

Yes you should be questioning food miles and sustainability, but if you'd bothered to read just a few of the posts below the article would very quickly have sussed that both Tesco and the EU do an immense amount to ensure H&S and that sourcing will not adversely impact on them.

Try http://mattsteinglass.wordpress.com/2008/05/19/thou-blackguard-thou-slanderest-my-fish/

Only reading one website will give you lots of data, maybe some information, but very little knowledge. Try googling beyond the highest answer!

Answered on

Well after reading the link that you posted River cobbler/Pangas I wont be having any more of that.
How can our supermarkets in developed countries buy such product without checking on such issues as what it has been fed on, the conditions that it has been grown/ raised and also what toxins the food may contain.
Thanks for the link Yernagates

Answered on

Another thing to ask about any farmed fish is, what are they being fed on? Often (don't know about river cobbler) it's small fish vacuumed out of the sea in a far from sustainable manner. It takes five to ten times the amount of such fish to produce farmed fish.

Then, where is it being done? Have fish-farm ponds been made in natural habitat, as happens with prawn farming in the Far East, where huge areas of important mangrove swamp has been destroyed.

And what about other impacts? Are the farms using water resources needed for other things? Do they produce effluent? Oh, and of course food miles...

Cobbler doesn't look good according to this page: http://www.dietmindspirit.org/2008/01/30/why-you-shouldnt-eat-this-fish-pangas-pangasius-vietnamese-river-cobbler-white-catfish-gray-sole/

Richard

To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • Our young chef hopefuls have been interviewed and we now have our five lucky finalists for #RisingStar 2014! WATCH: link
  • RT @BloomsburyCooks: You'll be able to take a 1st look at recipes from @rivercottage #LightandEasy in tomorrow's @thetimes - GET. EXCITED. …
  • RT @CornwallCollege: Looking forward to seeing entries for #EdenRisingStar chef competition! @edenproject @rivercottage Entry details here …
  • RT @edenproject: Interested in a chef apprenticeship with us? Watch this video: link #EdenRisingStar @rivercottage @Cornw
  • Did you know you can get paid to train at our @RCChefsSchool? Last places remaining: link link
  • RT @johnmushroom: @thepamthejam @rivercottage Quite right. When I rule the world, hedgerow-cutting dates will be taken under my personal co…
  • @thepamthejam @johnmushroom King John, gosh - now there's a thought!
  • RT @RCHQEvents: Beautiful day for a #wedding, congratulations Vicky & Paul! link
  • Join us next week for the highly anticipated launch of Hugh's book, River Cottage #lightandeasy. Last tickets left! link
  • RT @GSeabright: Enter #EdenRisingStar competition for chef apprenticeships with @edenproject @rivercottage @CornwallCollege https://t.co/e1…
  • @chellemars Yes our @GelfAlderson made it! The recipe isn't online but you can learn to make it on our course! :o) link
  • . @BBCRadio2 @achrisevans absolutely, we are ready! #TFIPieDay link
  • @RachaelWedd Enjoy! We can't take all the credit though, our @johnmushroom is the brains behind that one :o) @BloomsburyCooks
  • Time for another classic #Hugh recipe - cooled lettuce and radish soup: link @JamiesFoodTube link
  • RT @edenproject: Aged 16-24 and interested in a chef apprenticeship at Eden? Enter our #EdenRisingStar competition! Find out how http://t.c…
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: **TONIGHT** #Apprenticeship open evening here at @rivercottage HQ. 6.30pm - 8.30pm. Please share! link
  • RT @crowdfunderuk: Great catch up with @LeedsBreadCoop 1 year since their #crowdfunder campaign - did you pledge? link ht…
  • RT @RCHQEvents: Just announced, @FBPocketOrch will be joining us for Hugh's Late Summer Party! Grab one of the last tickets now: http://t.c…
  • RT @JamiesFoodTube: Start your morning right, with some classic @rivercottage. link
  • RT @crowdfunderuk: Guest blog: It’s been an exciting year for @SuttonFarm since their #crowdfunder campaign! link http://…
  • Our Hugh's a master in the kitchen, but he's #AtYourService for #StandUpToCancer. Book him to do anything you want! link
  • RT @RCHQEvents: Last places left for our One Day Cookery Course this Fri + Sun, call the team now for a late deal: 01297 630314: http://t.c…
  • @lucysiegle Absolutely, just follow us back and we'll send you a DM. Enjoy the pizza!
  • @lucysiegle Oh no! So sorry to hear that. Can you DM us more details so we can address the problem?
  • @BloomsburyCooks @PaulHollywood looks absolutely delicious!
  • VOTE: Support your favourite #RisingStar budding chef with just one click: link link
  • RT @starservice: A rustic @rivercottage meal from Hugh would be divine. But wouldn't it be SO much better if he read your nan a book? http:…
  • Get your hands on a signed copy of Hugh's new book and meet the man himself at our Late Summer Party. Book here: link
  • Chicken with lentils, rosemary + carrot cornbread. Sound good? It's on the menu at Hugh's book launch. Book now: link
  • St Clements polenta cake with blueberries. Salivating? Come and try it at Hugh's book launch on 4 Sept. Book here: link
  • RT @debsthelawyer: Fab day this week at @rivercottage HQ making bread and building a clay oven! link
  • Come along to Hugh's Late Summer Party on 4 Sept - meet Hugh & get his new book signed: link
  • Tweet your support for your favourite Rising Star hopeful and we’ll RT the lot! Get voting, folks! link
  • RT @GiulsMat: Vote for my friend CHLOE RIDE in the #RisingStar2014 competition for #RiverCottage. Here is her video - MAD SKILLS https://t.…
  • @lamornadavies You should be able to translate the website... it's in Danish :o)
  • Danish friends! Fancy a Booze masterclass with @johnmushroom? You are in luck! Don't miss @FoodFestivalDK https://t.co/eUucCIqDA1
  • Voting has just opened for this year’s Rising Star competition. See all the entrants here and pick your best! link
  • RT @KloEllaDeVille: Twitter buds! I'll be forever grateful if you could vote for me in the @rivercottage #RisingStar competition! http://t.…
  • And that's it! Entries for #RisingStar 2014 have closed. But you can still apply to be an #apprentice, more info: link
  • Just under an hour left to get your #RisingStar entries into us! Check out all the competitors so far, here: link
  • @charlotteella Even just a quick film on your mobile, talking about your pie and why you'd want to be our #RisingStar might be enough!
  • Four more entries overnight for #RisingStar! The deadline is midday today. You still have (just enough) time, GO! link
  • Tonight's the night, if you want to enter our Rising Star competition. Closes tomorrow! link link
  • WATCH! Only 24 hours to find 10 mins to enter Rising Star - it turned Sam’s life upside-down: link link
  • Only 24 hours to go to enter this year’s Rising Star and show us what you can do! RT, and spread the word! link
  • Think like @Biff_Stancombe you could be our new Rising Star? You’ve got a day to get your video over to us! link
  • Another top Rising Star entry, this time by Biff! Watch her Drunken White Rabbit recipe here: link link
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Whatever #GCSEresults you receive, we're here for you.Our award-winning #apprenticeship scheme has a few places left! ht…
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Amazing Rising Star entry from @Biff_Stancombe! Looks incredible. Watch and upload your own: link
  • RT @JamiesFoodTube: More #classic @rivercottage to get you through the day. Hugh whips up a seafood salsa for the crowds of @Bestival http:…
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00