Questions

Ask a question

Different type of fish

asked by David Hilton on
,

With us being urged at the moment to try different more sustainable types of fish I recently tried a new species that I have seen on display in a couple of supermarkets.
"River Cobbler". Apparently it is farmed in Vietnam. It was quite cheap, 99p for a decent size fillet.
What I would like to ask is ; with it being farmed in vietnam what quality of life does the fish have and are the fish farmers fairly paid for thier work.
It is no use us eating alternative fish to cod if that itself is going to result in other fish being bred in cramped conditions and third world people being exploited.
Can anyone throw any light on this fish?

4 answers
Answered on

The "thou blackguard" web page actually confirms many of the substantive things the other claims, apart from the pollution one. Industrial fish farming in specially dug ponds, fed on marine fish from one side of the world, product shipped to the other side...

I did not offer any opinion on cobbler itself: my post raised several questions which should be asked before buying any farmed fish. I can't yet find a source which answers them satisfactorily for this species.

Richard

Answered on

Sorry, but this is a scare story from 3 years ago in France, which had no foundation then, and does not now.

Yes you should be questioning food miles and sustainability, but if you'd bothered to read just a few of the posts below the article would very quickly have sussed that both Tesco and the EU do an immense amount to ensure H&S and that sourcing will not adversely impact on them.

Try http://mattsteinglass.wordpress.com/2008/05/19/thou-blackguard-thou-slanderest-my-fish/

Only reading one website will give you lots of data, maybe some information, but very little knowledge. Try googling beyond the highest answer!

Answered on

Well after reading the link that you posted River cobbler/Pangas I wont be having any more of that.
How can our supermarkets in developed countries buy such product without checking on such issues as what it has been fed on, the conditions that it has been grown/ raised and also what toxins the food may contain.
Thanks for the link Yernagates

Answered on

Another thing to ask about any farmed fish is, what are they being fed on? Often (don't know about river cobbler) it's small fish vacuumed out of the sea in a far from sustainable manner. It takes five to ten times the amount of such fish to produce farmed fish.

Then, where is it being done? Have fish-farm ponds been made in natural habitat, as happens with prawn farming in the Far East, where huge areas of important mangrove swamp has been destroyed.

And what about other impacts? Are the farms using water resources needed for other things? Do they produce effluent? Oh, and of course food miles...

Cobbler doesn't look good according to this page: http://www.dietmindspirit.org/2008/01/30/why-you-shouldnt-eat-this-fish-pangas-pangasius-vietnamese-river-cobbler-white-catfish-gray-sole/

Richard

To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • RT @thetimes: Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall on how his mum taught him to bake, only in today's @thetimes (@rivercottage) link
  • RT @comeconella: @rivercottage all things butternut! #cookeveryday
  • @JayAllen33 @RiverCottageHQ good question! Let's ask @lambposts...
  • RT @CoopFayB: @rivercottage blackberry & apple crumble. Perfect from the picking through to the eating. #cookeveryday
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage My fave autumn treat? It's spring in Oz, so I'm gonna say rhubarb!! #cookeveryday
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage My favourite autumn treat: has to be treacle toffee. #cookeveryday
  • Happy Monday all! #20 on #cookeveryday is favourite autumn treats (edible or otherwise) - let's hear them now... link
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage Veg I grow in my garden: None this year. I grow fruit and want to grow more veg, if slugs will let me! #coo…
  • RT @truss_abbie: @rivercottage #cookeveryday grow veg on my allotment but in the garden is fennel...lots of other herbs and wild garlic in …
  • #19 for #cookeveryday is all about veg. What do you grow in your garden? #growyourown link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: . @rivercottage we love ALL cheese, especially that made by @tomthecheese on our course! link #cooker…
  • RT @lisa_spelling: @rivercottage all of them!! But especially Waterloo and stinking bishop and sharpham rustic with a large glass of port! …
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage Cheese of choice? Too hard! I love them all! Something French, creamy & smelly... Mmm... #cookeveryday
  • Morning #cookeveryday fans! Time for #18, what's your favourite cheese? link
  • Hugh helped raise money for #StandUpToCancer with @starservice! Can you help too? link
  • RT @rose_rambles: @rivercottage My family's favourite cake to make & eat: vanilla sponge filled with cream & sliced pear #cookeveryday http…
  • RT @whitstabob: @rivercottage it's presently Lemon, lavender and almond because it's the only edible one I've ever made! link
  • #17 for #cookeveryday: what's your favourite cake to make / eat? Go! link
  • Hungry? Find high welfare meat retailers near you link @PigBusiness link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Come together to toast the #festive period with a seasonal aperitif & a roaring log fire in our yurt. Book now! http://…
  • RT @johnmushroom: @rivercottage #cookeveryday. Not yet mastered? Pastry. But how hard can it be? River Cottage Handbook needed, I think.
  • Keep your #cookeveryday answers coming - what cookery course would you like to do? What skill have you yet to master? link
  • Vote with your wallet. Watch @PigBusiness’ 3-minute video and sign the #PigPledge link
  • Today's #cookeveryday is: what's your ideal cookery course? What would you most like to learn? #cookeryschool
  • The new 3 minute #PigPledge video reveals the true cost of cheap pork - watch, share and sign! link
  • RT @BloomsburyCooks: Fantastic day today spent down in the farm @rivercottage - we got to ride on a tractor?! WINNING link
  • Keep your favourite chefs coming in - and remember to tag with #cookeveryday. Lots of love for @jamieoliver @rick_stein @Ottolenghi, Hugh...
  • RT @Lanzy_88: @rivercottage fav chefs wud have to be Hugh and the Hairy Bikers #cookeveryday
  • @hugo_harrison Assume you've seen Hugh's new one, #lightandeasy? It's packed with #wheatfree and #dairyfree recipes: link
  • RT @WinCanteen: Who's coming to meet Hugh tomorrow? He will be here at 10.30am to meet guests and sign his new book @rivercottage
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage My fave chef/cook..? I do love Hugh and @jamieoliver too. Keep fighting your good fights boys! #cookeveryday
  • RT @plymouthcanteen: The amazing talent Elise Yuill will be playing on Weds 15 October, come and enjoy beautiful music while you dine. http…
  • RT @ddtcm: @rivercottage #cookeveryday Keith Floyd. Full of enthusiasm and an inspiration. He was a legend.
  • RT @HappyDaysNo1: @rivercottage My favourite chefs are @jamieoliver @Rick_Stein & Hugh. 'Three Good Things'! #cookeveryday
  • RT @ar_weston: @rivercottage #cookeveryday My mom had never put a bad plate in front of me. :-)
  • Morning all, we want to hear your favourite chefs today for #cookeveryday - famous or otherwise. Go! link
  • RT @spanglotron: @rivercottage Hmmm French or Italian? French for variety? Robust and hearty to dainty and refined. Something for all seaso…
  • RT @HappyDaysNo1: @rivercottage my favourite cuisine has to be Chinese. #cookeveryday
  • RT @PigBusiness: .@rivercottage We completely agree! #PigPledge #Day2Welfare link
  • Sorry @davidwalliams - we knocked you off the #1 slot in the book chart x link
  • Hugh's #lightandeasy book is back at #1 in the chart. Got your copy yet? #wheatfree #dairyfree link @BloomsburyCooks
  • RT @NatalieKennedy: @rivercottage - favourite cuisine? got to be Indian! #cookeveryday
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage My favourite national cuisine... i couldn't choose between Mexican & Vietnamese... Yumm!!! #cookeveryday
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage Favourite national cuisine: Tough choice, but Italian gets my vote. #cookeveryday
  • So, if you had to pick just one national cuisine what would it be? Early votes in for Italian... #cookeveryday link
  • Don't miss Hugh on the #oneshow tonight - talking about his new book #lightandeasy. Tune in from 7pm @BBCOne
  • RT @wincanteen: We are looking for kitchen talent! Junior Sous and Chef de parties, more: link
  • We're asking for your school dinner memories today for #cookeveryday - did you love or hate?
  • RT @cruzinfloyd: @rivercottage ah! Cabbage and sprouts - hated at the time but now realise how hearty and healthy they were compared to to…
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Final week to apply for a @rivercottage #apprenticeship. Apply today and join our team: link http://t.…
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00