Blogs

Write new blog
HughFW

Fish Fight: Open letter to Dr. Ruth Brown

by HughFW published on
, ,

Dear Ruth, 

Thanks for taking the time to write with your views on the latest Fish Fight programme. I am sorry that you feel disillusioned with the campaign, and that you feel we misrepresented your views on Marine Protected Areas or the krill fishery. 

Let me respond to your points in the same order you presented them. You say that we implied that the research you do is paid for by license money received from the krill industry. In fact in the film it is Dr Martin Collins of the South Georgia Government who introduces the idea that the fisheries generate £3 million a year, and we specifically state in the voiceover “the bottom line is that the fisheries operating round South Georgia bring in 3m pounds a year for the Government, and that money is what keeps the whole place running”.

This is an accurate summery of Martin’s explanation to us on camera – and it contains no specific reference as to how the research programmes on the island are funded. We never said or implied that the research on Bird Island, or anywhere else, was funded by krill fisheries or any other fisheries. 

You seem disappointed that we never once mentioned BAS, CCAMLR, or NERC. This is because television needs to work hard to make complicated ideas and stories comprehensible and accessible to a wide audience, and including acronyms and too many auxiliary parts to the story often works against this guiding principal. We do however explain clearly that there is an “international management body” which sets quotas for the krill boats (ie CCAMLR), we just never mention it by its name.

When we talked about penguin populations declining, and we did this more than once during the programme, we made it clear that what is known is that penguins are declining due to habitat loss. What we actually said is that “It is not yet known what effect fishing  for krill might have on this fragile ecosystem”, and again later in the programme “What is harder to measure is the effect that the growing krill fishing industry is having on the local wildlife”. It is precisely because of this uncertainty that we go on to talk about the need for “future proofing” our oceans, and setting up more restrictions on the fisheries working in those areas, management plans which we are delighted to see are currently being discussed and implemented. 

You say that fur seals have undergone a population explosion in recent years in South Georgia and that we fail to mention this fact in our programme. What we actually say (over shots of lots and lots of fur seals) is that the populations of whales and seals around these islands are “almost back to pre-hunting levels. In fact South Georgia has now become the most important breeding site in the world for fur seals”, which I think gets the point across.

You say that it is misleading to suggest that all the whales have recovered to pre-hunting levels, and I agree, we may have over-simplified this point, and I’m happy to post a clarification on our website along the lines of: “During our latest Fish Fight programme we gave the impression that all the whale species around South Georgia have recovered to their pre-hunting levels. In fact, although humpback whales have shown strong recovery, Blue Whales and fin whales haven’t yet recovered to pre-hunting levels, and there is a lack of data on Sei whales and Antarctic Minke whales.” Perhaps you, or others working at BAS could help to clarify these facts?

You are right that we didn’t include the fact that the Saga Sea has little or no bycatch while it is fishing for krill. We did film a sequence talking about this on board the boat, but due to a lack of time, we did not include it in our final edit. As I mentioned before, it is important to keep the story telling of a TV documentary clear and simple, and as you know, bycatch is not something we are looking at in this series, having covered it so comprehensively in the first series of Fish Fight 2 years ago. I do not feel that this omission misrepresents our story in any way. 

You conclude by saying that our programme was poorly researched and misleading, and suggest that we came to South Georgia with preconceived ideas of what we wanted to film. I can assure you, however, that we take great pride in getting our facts right, and putting across forceful and engaging arguments to our viewers to try to encourage them to take an interest in marine conservation issues. Although we thoroughly research our stories before we leave the office, we never arrive on location with preconceived ideas of what we will discover there.

One of the joys of documentary making is filming what you find, and following the stories that emerge on the ground. Unfortunately, when we arrived on South Georgia, it appeared to us that everyone we were due to film had been briefed about what they could and could not say to us. It was later confirmed that a briefing from the BAS press office and representatives of the South Georgia Government had indeed taken place before our arrival in South Georgia. This made it quite difficult for us to feel like we were ever getting heartfelt and true responses to our questions. 

I hope this answers some of your queries and concerns, and that we can continue to have an informed and productive conversations about marine protected areas and how best to manage the astonishing seas round the Southern Oceans.

All best wishes,

Hugh 

1 reply
Replied on

Hi Hugh,
The episode about Krill fishing in South Georgia made a huge impact on me...as no doubt it did on many people around the globe...
It was horrifying to see how even this "supposedly" protected and "pristine" area is being stripped of the very food that sustains so many sea creatures...and totally disgusting that most of the tonnes and tonnes of Krill are used for Pet Food!!....I mean...really!!...and I don't know HOW much research there has been done about the "benefits" of us humans taking krill oil...

How greedy do we have to be as humans??

I hope with all my heart that something will be done about this situation ....but that may well be a naïve thought !!
Our beautiful world is being stuffed up every which way!! When are people going to wake up?

To leave a response to the post you will need to be a registered user. Sign-up here or Login here
@rivercottage
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage Veg I grow in my garden: None this year. I grow fruit and want to grow more veg, if slugs will let me! #coo…
  • RT @truss_abbie: @rivercottage #cookeveryday grow veg on my allotment but in the garden is fennel...lots of other herbs and wild garlic in …
  • #19 for #cookeveryday is all about veg. What do you grow in your garden? #growyourown link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: . @rivercottage we love ALL cheese, especially that made by @tomthecheese on our course! link #cooker…
  • RT @lisa_spelling: @rivercottage all of them!! But especially Waterloo and stinking bishop and sharpham rustic with a large glass of port! …
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage Cheese of choice? Too hard! I love them all! Something French, creamy & smelly... Mmm... #cookeveryday
  • Morning #cookeveryday fans! Time for #18, what's your favourite cheese? link
  • Hugh helped raise money for #StandUpToCancer with @starservice! Can you help too? link
  • RT @rose_rambles: @rivercottage My family's favourite cake to make & eat: vanilla sponge filled with cream & sliced pear #cookeveryday http…
  • RT @whitstabob: @rivercottage it's presently Lemon, lavender and almond because it's the only edible one I've ever made! link
  • #17 for #cookeveryday: what's your favourite cake to make / eat? Go! link
  • Hungry? Find high welfare meat retailers near you link @PigBusiness link
  • RT @RiverCottageHQ: Come together to toast the #festive period with a seasonal aperitif & a roaring log fire in our yurt. Book now! http://…
  • RT @johnmushroom: @rivercottage #cookeveryday. Not yet mastered? Pastry. But how hard can it be? River Cottage Handbook needed, I think.
  • Keep your #cookeveryday answers coming - what cookery course would you like to do? What skill have you yet to master? link
  • Vote with your wallet. Watch @PigBusiness’ 3-minute video and sign the #PigPledge link
  • Today's #cookeveryday is: what's your ideal cookery course? What would you most like to learn? #cookeryschool
  • The new 3 minute #PigPledge video reveals the true cost of cheap pork - watch, share and sign! link
  • RT @BloomsburyCooks: Fantastic day today spent down in the farm @rivercottage - we got to ride on a tractor?! WINNING link
  • Keep your favourite chefs coming in - and remember to tag with #cookeveryday. Lots of love for @jamieoliver @rick_stein @Ottolenghi, Hugh...
  • RT @Lanzy_88: @rivercottage fav chefs wud have to be Hugh and the Hairy Bikers #cookeveryday
  • @hugo_harrison Assume you've seen Hugh's new one, #lightandeasy? It's packed with #wheatfree and #dairyfree recipes: link
  • RT @WinCanteen: Who's coming to meet Hugh tomorrow? He will be here at 10.30am to meet guests and sign his new book @rivercottage
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage My fave chef/cook..? I do love Hugh and @jamieoliver too. Keep fighting your good fights boys! #cookeveryday
  • RT @plymouthcanteen: The amazing talent Elise Yuill will be playing on Weds 15 October, come and enjoy beautiful music while you dine. http…
  • RT @ddtcm: @rivercottage #cookeveryday Keith Floyd. Full of enthusiasm and an inspiration. He was a legend.
  • RT @HappyDaysNo1: @rivercottage My favourite chefs are @jamieoliver @Rick_Stein & Hugh. 'Three Good Things'! #cookeveryday
  • RT @ar_weston: @rivercottage #cookeveryday My mom had never put a bad plate in front of me. :-)
  • Morning all, we want to hear your favourite chefs today for #cookeveryday - famous or otherwise. Go! link
  • RT @spanglotron: @rivercottage Hmmm French or Italian? French for variety? Robust and hearty to dainty and refined. Something for all seaso…
  • RT @HappyDaysNo1: @rivercottage my favourite cuisine has to be Chinese. #cookeveryday
  • RT @PigBusiness: .@rivercottage We completely agree! #PigPledge #Day2Welfare link
  • Sorry @davidwalliams - we knocked you off the #1 slot in the book chart x link
  • Hugh's #lightandeasy book is back at #1 in the chart. Got your copy yet? #wheatfree #dairyfree link @BloomsburyCooks
  • RT @NatalieKennedy: @rivercottage - favourite cuisine? got to be Indian! #cookeveryday
  • RT @renc_g: @rivercottage My favourite national cuisine... i couldn't choose between Mexican & Vietnamese... Yumm!!! #cookeveryday
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage Favourite national cuisine: Tough choice, but Italian gets my vote. #cookeveryday
  • So, if you had to pick just one national cuisine what would it be? Early votes in for Italian... #cookeveryday link
  • Don't miss Hugh on the #oneshow tonight - talking about his new book #lightandeasy. Tune in from 7pm @BBCOne
  • RT @wincanteen: We are looking for kitchen talent! Junior Sous and Chef de parties, more: link
  • We're asking for your school dinner memories today for #cookeveryday - did you love or hate?
  • RT @cruzinfloyd: @rivercottage ah! Cabbage and sprouts - hated at the time but now realise how hearty and healthy they were compared to to…
  • RT @RCChefsSchool: Final week to apply for a @rivercottage #apprenticeship. Apply today and join our team: link http://t.…
  • RT @ChildFoodTrust: Great topic of the day from @rivercottage ... school dinners! #cookeveryday
  • RT @Befuggled: @rivercottage Horror of school meals still haunts me. Stench of over cooked spuds, bony fish pie and inedible, gristly heart…
  • RT @violetpsyche: @rivercottage School dinners: Loved them! They were cooked on-site in the school kitchen. I used to go back for seconds. …
  • RT @Maddilion1875: @rivercottage #cookeveryday they weren't great, but they weren't bad either. Spam fritters I remember and vats of semoli…
  • Today's #13 #cookeveryday is going to divide opinion. School dinners - did you love or hate? link
  • RT @gillben1: @johnmushroom @rivercottage I am just discovering the delights of rosehip syrup and bubbly. #cookeveryday
  • RT @corditekid: @rivercottage a Tom Collins or a Screwdriver, simple and taste good! #cookeveryday
Login or Sign-up

Login & Sign-up

Forgotten your password? Retrieve it here
Or connect via Facebook
Connect with Facebook
Join River Cottage
Close
Shopping basket: 0 items £0.00